My absolute gratitude to Caitlin McCoy at Harper Collins for sending me a surprise copy of The Wild Beneath by Kelly Anderson. I’m delighted to share my review of The Wild Beneath today.
The Wild Beneath will be published by HQ on 27th August 2026 and is available for purchase through the publisher links here.
The Wild Beneath

The pull of the land or the call of the sea…
Annie MacLeod always knew she was different, growing up on a sailboat, navigating by stars and swimming with sea creatures, alongside her best friend, Evan. But when a tsunami hits, Annie is stranded on land; her entire world, and her eccentric identity, torn apart and upended.
In the wreckage, she rescues a wordless man named Walker, who emits a hum only she can hear. Their connection is instant. Walker’s touch gives Annie visions of the ocean’s hidden world, a life she’s never known but feels inexplicably drawn to. Yet even as she is pulled toward him, Evan – the steadfast love who has always been there – remains on dry land, offering stability and security. Annie is torn between Evan’s grounding presence and Walker’s magnetic secrets. But then, Walker vanishes, along with the answers Annie needs about who she really is.
Six years later, Annie has left the sea and buried the past – until Walker returns, pulling her back towards the ocean and the life she abandoned. The truth has roots more ancient than she ever could have known, and Annie must confront a choice that will test her heart and determine her future.
A fierce and entrancing debut novel of one woman caught between two worlds that won’t let her go.
My Review of The Wild Beneath
A tsunami has shattered Annie MacLeod’s world.
This. This is exactly what a book should be. The Wild Beneath is utterly, utterly wonderful and I could not have loved it more.
The plot of The Wild Beneath is mesmerising. I felt the pull of the narrative every moment I wasn’t reading so that my experience was akin to Annie’s experiences – she is pulled by the sea, by her relationships with Walker and Evan and by the sounds reverberating through her body. When I wasn’t reading The Wild Beneath, I was thinking about it. It permeated my thoughts continuously.
It’s impossible to categorise The Wild Beneath. In part it’s a magical fantasy, drawing on traditional fables of merfolk, in part it’s a love story and it’s also a coming of age narrative. Alongside these aspects The Wild Beneath is also an ecological story. But what it is above anything else, is an intangible, pulsating tale that is far, far greater than the sum of its parts. It is, quite simply, superb.
Kelly Anderson’s prose is beautiful. With the briefest of sentences she conveys a profound depth of emotion. The writing is as fluid, varied and immersive as the sea against which the narrative is set. I adored the division of the story into the four phases of tides because it gave unity and coherence whilst allowing the wildness and capriciousness of the sea to be explored. Direct speech is natural and so engaging that it feels so intimate and real it is as if the reader is eavesdropping on the characters. The Wild Beneath is an absolute masterclass in emotive and immersive writing.
The characters are magnificent. Each is unable to be truly themselves, each needs to learn to listen not only to others, but to the universe, and, more importantly, to their own innermost pulse of life – to the wild beneath. Through Walker, Annie and Evan learn that listening skill. This is a story that illustrates how we can be true to ourselves. Walker is magical, mythical, magnificent. He is the drum beat at the heart of Annie.
Annie is superbly depicted. She is every bit her mother’s daughter and yet she is as individual as it is possible to be. Her love for both Walker and Evan is as instinctive and raw as it is possible to be so that I had no idea how the story would resolve or whether I had the emotional strength to find out, whilst being unable to draw myself away. My heart ached for her.
Whilst I was completely captivated by Annie’s character development and the love story that surrounds her, other themes enthralled me too. In The Wild Beneath Kelly Anderson considers what constitutes family. Mara and Ruth have very different approaches to caring for Annie but it is obvious they are both doing their best within their own parameters. Kelly Anderson looks at mental and physical health and how they are affected by lifestyle and pressure to work or conform, especially through Evan’s relationship with his father. She also considers the environment as the sea disgorges objects through the tsunami and Isaac logs the trees. These themes may sound ‘worthy’ but they are woven with such dexterity into the narrative they simply make it even more multi-layered and engrossing.
It’s impossible to articulate filly my views of The Wild beneath. I feel my review has barely scratched the surface. Metamorphic, magical and moving, The Wild Beneath is absolutely fantastic and I adored it unconditionally. What. A. Book.
Read it and discover how to listen to the beat of your own essence!
About Kelly Anderson
Dr. Kelly Anderson is a family physician with fellowships in HIV and emergency medicine. She has worked extensively in rural and remote emergency departments, spent fifteen years at the Inner City Family Health Team at St. Michael’s Hospital in Toronto, and built the clinical team at Felix Health. After completing the Bookends Novel Fellowship, she trained in the Gateless Writing Academy and is a certified Gateless writing teacher. Kelly spent much of her childhood in British Columbia, and now lives in Guelph, Ontario with her family. The Wild Beneath is her first novel.
For further information, visit Kelly’s website and find her on Instagram .




























